Public and Private Realms Make Urbanism

Measuring Life (or the Inherent Value of Mixed-Use)

Economic Development

“Housing is not simple… It is shelter, and it is also a financial asset, a retirement strategy, a tax base, and a source of local wealth, all shaped by regulations and finance systems and migration patterns and interest rates and demographics in ways that interact and resist clean summary.” – Chuck Marohn

Expanding on the elements of Housing (Live) complexity to Work, Play, Learn, Govern, Heal, Move, and Worship at the Neighborhood/Transit Center Scale (160-acres), Within each activity is a list of how they affect the private individual person, private company, and public entity. The intention is to be a useful measuring matrix of mixed-use neighborhoods outcomes in economic and social terms (environmental is later). These are the details of Leon Krier’s Civitas cartoon depicting the public/private/collective realms that build cities we live our daily, weekly, monthly, seasonal, annual lives within. 

THE INSTITUTIONS OF A DAILY LIFE x LIFE CYCLE – PRIMARY/secondary Realms

Housing (Live) – PRIVATE/public

  • Detached Housing
  • Attached Housing
    • Public Housing
    • Senior Housing
    • Homeless Facilities
    • Emergency Facilities

Shops (Work – Retail and Commerce) – PRIVATE

  • In-Home Offices/Shops
  • Attached Inline Shops
    • Specialty Centers (Lifestyle, Power, Strip Malls)
  • Detached Shops (Standalone or Inline)
    • Retail shopping
    • Dining and Entertainments
    • Specialty Stores
    • Grocery Stores
    • Professional Offices
    • Workshops
    • Storage Facilities
    • Manufacturing
    • Resorts

Play (Parks, Recreation, and Nature) – PUBLIC/Private

  • Indoor
    • Gyms, private
    • Swimming Pools
    • Race Tracks
  • Outdoor
    • Gyms, private
    • Recreation (golf courses, racing tracks), private
    • Amusement Parks (zoos), public/private
    • Plazas, Squares, Greens
    • Sports fields, golf courses
    • Equestrian facilities, private
    • Nature reserves, preserves, parks trail access
    • Water features, bays, shores, estuaries, creeks, streams, and rivers
    • Steep slopes, canyons, and unbuildable areas

Learn – PUBLIC/PRIVATE

  • K – 12, Public
  • K – 12, Private and Religious
  • Higher and Trade Education, Public (City and State) and Private
  • Day Care

Worship (Churches, Temples, Mosques) – PUBLIC/PRIVATE

  • Places of Ceremony
  • Education
  • Cemeteries

Governance – PUBLIC (Local, State, Federal)

  • Military Facilities (State and Federal)
  • Jails
  • Certificates
    • Birth, Marriage, Death, Driving, etc…
  • Emergency Services, Fire, Police, Ambulance
  • Tax Collection, Distribution
  • Local Post Offices, Libraries
  • Municipal Governance offices
  • Federal, State, City Courthouses, Jails
  • State Agencies hearing rooms and offices
  • City Hall, City Facilities
  • Community/Town Halls
  • Cemeteries

Health Care – PUBLIC/PRIVATE

  • Medical offices
  • Hospice care clinics
  • Outpatient clinics
  • Inpatient Hospitals
    • Births, Emergency, Deaths

Mobility – PUBLIC/PRIVATE

  • Streets and Transit Facilities, Public
  • Automobile and delivery services, Private
  • Freight trucks, private
  • Parking on/off-street, garage facilities, public and private
  • Port Facilities, public/private
    • Airplanes
    • Trains
    • Ships

More Details of each of these interact with the private Individual, private business, and public government.

Housing interacts with:

FOR PRIVATE INDIVIDUALS

  • shelter
  • financial asset
  • retirement strategy
  • source of local wealth
  • social connections

FOR PRIVATE BUSINESSES

  • financial asset
  • interest rates
  • finance systems

FOR PUBLIC ENTITIES

  • tax base
  • finance systems
  • migration patterns
  • demographics
  • shaped by regulations
  • revenue source

Business interacts with:

FOR PRIVATE INDIVIDUALS

  • source of income
  • financial asset
  • retirement strategy
  • source of local wealth
  • social connections

FOR PRIVATE BUSINESSES

  • financial asset
  • interest rates
  • finance systems

FOR PUBLIC ENTITIES

  • tax base
  • finance systems
  • migration patterns
  • demographics
  • shaped by regulations
  • organizational connections
  • revenue source

Recreating interacts with:

FOR PRIVATE INDIVIDUALS

  • personal respite/joy
  • personal enhancement
  • social connection
  • to play or perform

FOR PRIVATE BUSINESSES

  • employee supply/retention
  • financial investment
  • finance systems

FOR PUBLIC ENTITIES

  • revenue expense
  • finance systems
  • citizen/taxpayer supply/retention
  • demographics
  • shaped by regulations

Learning interacts with:

FOR PRIVATE INDIVIDUALS

  • personal enhancement
  • business strategy
  • financial asset
  • retirement strategy
  • social connection
  • source of future wealth
  • interest rates on loans (indebtedness)

FOR PRIVATE BUSINESSES

  • employee supply/retention
  • financial investment
  • finance systems

FOR PUBLIC ENTITIES

  • tax base
  • finance systems
  • migration patterns
  • demographics
  • shaped by regulations
  • organizational connections

Worshiping interacts with:

FOR PRIVATE INDIVIDUALS

  • personal enhancement
  • social connection
  • moral pattern

FOR PRIVATE BUSINESSES

  • financial systems
  • education

FOR PUBLIC ENTITIES

  • demographics
  • organizational connections

Governance interacts with:

FOR PRIVATE INDIVIDUALS

  • funding source
  • personal connection
  • social connection
  • moral pattern
  • education

FOR PRIVATE BUSINESSES

  • funding source
  • political connections
  • financial systems

FOR PUBLIC ENTITIES

  • expenditures/investments (subsidies)
  • finance systems (subsidies)
  • mobility/access patterns (streets)
  • health (code enforcement/parks)
  • welfare (code enforcement/parks)
  • safety (policy, fire, code enforcement)
  • policies/regulations (housing/mobility)
  • demographics
  • organizational connections

Health Care interacts with:

FOR PRIVATE INDIVIDUALS

  • health, welfare, safety
  • financial expenditure
  • safety net
  • birth, life, death (cradle to grave)

FOR PRIVATE BUSINESSES

  • employee supply/retention
  • financial investment,
  • financial / employee burden
  • finance systems

FOR PUBLIC ENTITIES

  • mobility/access patterns (streets)
  • health (code enforcement/parks)
  • welfare (code enforcement/parks)
  • safety (policy, fire, code enforcement)
  • policies/regulations (housing/mobility)

Mobility interacts with:

FOR PRIVATE INDIVIDUALS

  • accessing the region, nation
  • accessing home
  • accessing employment
  • accessing recreation/health care services
  • (we buy private autos and fuel with access to public transportation and road facilities)

FOR PRIVATE BUSINESSES

  • employee access
  • client access
  • sales access
  • distribution connection/access (planes, trains, trucks, boats)

FOR PUBLIC ENTITIES

  • mobility/access patterns (streets and transit facilities)
  • planes, trains, and shipping (commerce controlled by regional agencies, port/airport/rail agencies)
  • safety (policy, fire, code enforcement)
  • policies/regulations (housing/mobility)
  • expenditures/investments (subsidies)
  • finance systems (subsidies)
  • (we pay taxes to maintain thoroughfares for commerce and access)

Leave a comment